A Gold and Silver IRA allows you to diversify your retirement savings with precious metals. Choosing the right provider is crucial for secure storage, competitive fees, and excellent customer service.
At Top10.compare, we have reviewed the best Gold and Silver IRA companies to help you find the right one for your retirement goals.
Best Gold and Silver IRA Companies of 2025
American Hartford Gold – Best Overall
Goldco – Best for Beginners
American Gold and Silver Group – Best Promotions
Preserve Gold – Best Transparency
Priority Gold – Best Value
American Hartford Gold - Industry leader for large account balances with A+ BBB rating. Learn more about American Hartford Gold
- A+ rating with Better Business Bureau
- 5-star customer rating on Trustpilot and Google
- Buyback commitment with no liquidation fees
- Rollovers from 401(k), IRA, TSP, and more
- Free consultations and 100% satisfaction guarantee
- Inc. 5000 honoree - America's Fastest-Growing Companies
Goldco - Guided Gold IRA rollovers with over $3 billion in metals placements. Learn more about Goldco
- Over $3 billion in metals placements
- A+ BBB rating, 4.8/5 Trustpilot from 1,500+ reviews
- No purchase minimums as of 2025
- Dedicated account specialists for guided rollovers
- Buyback guarantee with flexible exit options
- Free educational materials for beginners
American Gold and Silver Group - Up to $15,000 free silver and 5 years free storage. Learn more about American Gold and Silver Group
- Up to $15,000 in free silver for qualified accounts
- Up to 5 years free storage on select accounts
- Free insured shipping
- Streamlined IRA setup with quick account opening
- IRS-approved storage facilities
- Gold, silver, platinum, and palladium available
Preserve Gold - Zero hidden fees with up to 5 years waived storage and price matching. Learn more about Preserve Gold
- Zero hidden fees - transparent upfront pricing
- Up to 5 years waived storage and custodian fees
- Price matching guarantee and zero-fee buyback
- 24-hour purchase guarantee with no-penalty cancellation
- A+ BBB, 5.0 ConsumerAffairs, 4.8+ Trustpilot
- Lifetime dedicated account specialist
Priority Gold - America's Precious Metals IRA Company of the Year. Learn more about Priority Gold
- America's Precious Metals IRA Company of the Year
- No fees for up to 10 years (setup, storage, custodian)
- Lowest price guarantee, zero buyback fees
- Ranked #1 by Forbes & Financial Services Review
- Endorsed by Robert Kiyosaki
- Free insured shipping and U.S. vault storage
Augusta Precious Metals - The Premier Choice for Sophisticated Investors with an Education-First Process. Learn more about Augusta Precious Metals
- Education: One-on-one conferences with a Harvard-trained economist.
- Transparency: No hidden fees and a strict "no gimmicks" policy regarding free silver.
- Support: Lifetime account service with specialized departments for every stage.
- Ethics: High ratings from all major watchdogs and a no-pressure sales model.
For everyday investors who want personalized guidance. Learn more about Birch Gold
- Accessibility: Low $10,000 minimum for IRAs and $5,000 for cash.
- Service: Dedicated "Precious Metals Specialist" for every account.
- Selection: Offers all four precious metals: Gold, Silver, Platinum, and Palladium.
- Incentives: First-year fees waived for transfers over $50,000.
Why Trust Top10.Compare?
Top10.Compare goes beyond basic lists. Our mission is to help you make smarter investment choices by providing independent, transparent, and expert-driven comparisons. We focus on practical research, industry expertise, and real-world value for your retirement portfolio.
1. American Hartford Gold – Best Overall
Pros
- Strong reputation: A+ BBB rating and 5-star reviews on Trustpilot and Google
- Buyback guarantee with no liquidation fees for easy exit options
- Flexible rollover support from 401(k)s, IRAs, TSPs, and other retirement accounts
- Comprehensive metals selection: gold, silver, platinum, and palladium
- Free consultations and educational resources for new investors
Cons
-
Minimum investment of $10,000 for Gold IRA may exclude some investors
-
Annual fees ($230 application, $200 storage) apply though may be waived for larger accounts
-
Physical metals cannot be stored at home in an IRA (IRS requirement)
2. Goldco – Best for Beginners
Pros
- Over $3 billion in metals placements with proven track record
- A+ BBB rating, 4.8/5 Trustpilot from 1,500+ reviews
- No purchase minimums as of 2025
- Dedicated account specialists for guided rollovers
- Buyback guarantee with flexible exit options
- Free educational materials for beginners
Cons
-
Premium pricing compared to some competitors
-
Free silver promotion requires minimum purchase threshold
3. American Gold and Silver Group – Best Promotions
Pros
- Up to $15,000 in free silver for qualified accounts
- Up to 5 years free storage on select accounts
- Free insured shipping
- Streamlined IRA setup with quick account opening
- IRS-approved storage facilities
- Gold, silver, platinum, and palladium available
Cons
-
Newer company with less established track record
-
Promotional terms may vary
4. Preserve Gold – Best Transparency
Pros
- Zero hidden fees - transparent upfront pricing
- Up to 5 years waived storage and custodian fees
- Price matching guarantee and zero-fee buyback
- 24-hour purchase guarantee with no-penalty cancellation
- A+ BBB, 5.0 ConsumerAffairs, 4.8+ Trustpilot
- Lifetime dedicated account specialist
Cons
-
Founded in 2022, relatively new in the industry
-
Cashback promotion has specific qualifying terms
5. Priority Gold – Best Value
Pros
- America's Precious Metals IRA Company of the Year
- No fees for up to 10 years (setup, storage, custodian)
- Lowest price guarantee, zero buyback fees
- Ranked #1 by Forbes & Financial Services Review
- Endorsed by Robert Kiyosaki
- Free insured shipping and U.S. vault storage